Posted by Athena Scalzi
https://whatever.scalzi.com/2025/05/07/an-appyhour-double-feature/
https://whatever.scalzi.com/?p=55545
I never got around to posting March’s box from AppyHour, or April’s, for that matter, so I’m going to do both in this one post. Woohoo!
If you happened to miss my posts over AppyHour’s January and February boxes, AppyHour is a subscription based charcuterie company that mails board-ready artisan goods right to your door. Meats, cheeses, crackers, nuts, spreads, all you need is a board to put them on!
So let’s dive right into what I got in my March box. The theme was “Old World Tavern,” a theme I was particularly excited for. I can’t deny that always I’ve dreamt of being a D&D innkeeper, serving the heroic party of misfits a meal and some ale. Feel free to follow along in the tasting guide.
Here’s what March entailed:

We’ve got dried Sierra figs, a California clothbound cheddar, a basil pesto gouda, a wedge of Dragon Slayer, honey & herb prosciutto, a Spanish cocktail nut mix, Blake Hill’s red pepper jelly, Blake Hill’s French onion spread, beef & caraway salami, and Martin’s Handmade Pretzels.
A closer look at the basil pesto gouda:

Hailing from Wisconsin, this semi-firm cow’s milk gouda is made with imported Dutch ingredients. It’s also crafted by Marieke Peterman, one of the few women who holds the prestigious title of “Wisconsin Master Cheesemaker.” But how does it taste? Personally, gouda is one of my favorite cheeses, and this cheese did not disappoint. It had a soft, creamy texture and a lovely herbaceous flavor that I really enjoyed. This would definitely be a crowd pleaser on any board.
Now presenting the California clothbound cheddar:

All the way from Modesto, this cow’s milk cheese was actually made exclusively with the farmstead’s very own cows. It’s aged in cheesecloth for fourteen months and crumbles beautifully into perfect bite size pieces as a result. You seriously can’t go wrong with a cheddar, and this one is no different. Savory, slightly nutty, super tasty all around. We all really liked this one, it’s definitely something I would gladly put on a board again!
For our last cheese, the one I was most excited about, the Dragon Slayer:

Another cow’s milk cheddar, this one is made with mustard seeds and ale. I absolutely love whole grain mustard, so having this cheese be full of mustard seeds was a real treat. It was bold and tangy, with a surprisingly smooth, buttery type of texture. It was well balanced while still having plenty of mustard flavor, and I like how brightly colored the rind is (don’t eat the rind).
And here’s the salami after I sliced it up:

Getting the casing off this sucker was a bit of a pain, but once the casing is off you’re left with a savory, flavorful salami that is surprisingly tender in texture. This salami was very dark in color, like darker than any other salami I’ve seen before, which I found kind of interesting. I liked how when I cut it into pieces, they each had a funky, unique shape. Made for a more interesting presentation on the board.
Here’s what I ended up doing with everything:

I served the pretzels and some other crackers I had on hand on the side, as it was a smaller sized board. The prosciutto was good but I’m not sure if I really tasted honey or herbs. The figs were excellent, sweet and rich. I didn’t care for the nut mix, but I absolutely loved the red pepper jelly. The French onion spread I also had in my January box, and it’s pretty good, too. The pretzels were super duper crunchy, and I like that each one is hand-twisted.
Overall, I was really happy with this box! I loved the cheeses, the figs, and the spreads. The meats were good and honestly I can get over some mid nuts.
So let’s see what April had:

The theme for April was Spain (here’s the tasting guide). We’ve got a Mahon Menorca (DOP), a chub of ramp salami, a Queso de Murcia al Vino (DOP), some Jamón Serrano, a mandarin orange spread, a blackberry rosemary jam, and a Wooly Wooly Diablo.
Also, my mom was a bit of a goober and accidentally threw away the box before taking out everything in it, so not pictured is a bag of Piri Piri Cocktail Mix (peanuts, cashews, rice crisps, fava beans, and fried corn, seasoned with piri piri), and a box of Jennifer’s Homemade breadsticks (I love those things).
Okay, so, I had definitely never heard of any of those cheeses before, and I didn’t know what DOP meant. So, if you also don’t know, it stands for Denominazione d’Origine Protetta, which translates to Protected Designation of Origin. Essentially, it guarantees that whatever product you’re buying, whether it’s cheese, prosciutto, olive oil, etc., is made from a specific location. So if these cheeses say they’re from Spain and have that DOP label, they’re definitely made and packaged in Spain. Hooray for learning something new!
I feel like you can actually see the cheese pretty clearly in the unboxing photo, so I won’t do individual close up shots of those, but here’s the ramp salami:

I have never had ramps before, but when I found out about them last year from one of my favorite food bloggers, I really wanted to try them. If you haven’t heard of them before, ramps are like a wild onion/leek type plant that grow in North America in the springtime. They are said to have a very pungent smell and flavor.
Lemme tell ya, this salami smelled FUNKY. I opened the paper it was in and was immediately like phewww. It smelled kind of like feet? It was very strange and very strong, and I hoped when I took off the casing (which was a pain to get off) that it wouldn’t be so strong. The actual taste of the salami was seriously toned down compared to the smell, but still very pungent and funky. So this salami was a bit more of an acquired taste, I fear. As for texture, it was extremely buttery with huge pockets of fat throughout. This was a weird one for sure.
Here’s the board I made:

Okay hold on she’s prettyyyy though! I really like how this board turned out! I ended up having to use some stuff I had on hand since I didn’t have the nuts or crackers from the box, so I used Snack Factory Pretzel Crisps and some pita thins I can’t remember the brand of, plus some random package of trail mix for the nuts/dried fruit accompaniment. I also threw some blueberries on there for a fresh, colorful component, as well as some mint from my herb garden for a nice garnish.
Let’s get a close up shot and talk about the cheeses:

It turns out I did know what one of the cheeses was. The Queso de Murcia al Vino is a “drunken goat” cheese! I love drunken goat cheese and every time I put it on a board, people tend to really like it. It’s a goat cheese that’s been soaked in wine, giving the rind a beautiful purple color (don’t eat the rind). Every time I use it, I make sure to cut it and present it in a way that shows the rind. It’s semi-soft and perfect to cut into pretty triangles, lovely and creamy and is not overwhelming if you’re someone who typically doesn’t care for goat cheese. Great addition!
As for the Mahon Menorca, it’s a cow’s milk cheese made on an island in the Mediterranean that reminds me a lot of a cheddar with its crumbly texture and sort of sharper flavor. Not too sharp, though, as it still has some buttery-ness to it. The rind is rubbed with olive oil and paprika which gave it a really pretty rind, but the rind is inedible so that seems unfortunate to me.
The Wooly Wooly Diablo is a sheep’s milk cheese, so I really liked that this box had a goat cheese, cow cheese, and sheep’s cheese. Normally, sheep cheese is a little too much for me, with its funkiness and pungent smell, but this was much less intense, more like a Manchego. The name and description would lead you to believe that it’s a spicy cheese, since it’s made with mojo picón, but it wasn’t spicy at all. I’m thankful for that, but I think if you’re someone who likes spicy stuff and buys a cheese with the word “diablo” in it, it should be a little spicy!
Apparently the rind is listed as inedible, but uhh.. we definitely ate it, so.
As for the other meat on this board, the serrano was very similar to prosciutto, in fact so similar that I definitely wouldn’t know the difference if I wasn’t told it. But I absolutely love prosciutto so this serrano is still totally a win in my book, I thought it was great. There’s beauty in simplicity, and this aged, Spanish dry-cured ham is proof of that.
So, how were the spreads? Absolutely bomb. Both the orange spread and the blackberry spread were so delish, we totally cleaned out both little jars. The mandarin orange spread had some pieces of peel in it but wasn’t bitter at all, and the blackberry spread is made with rosemary, giving it that warm, holiday-esque flavor. I have no idea what brand they were but they were both the same brand and they rocked.
So, there you have it! Another board in the books, and I’m really looking forward to the May box since the theme is “Fields in Bloom.” If you want to try AppyHour and get $20 off your first box, I actually have a different referral code now than I previously did, so make sure you use this one if you want to try it. I have so many $20 off from you guys using my link that I’ll probably be doing these posts for the next year (slightly joking, but also it’s kind of true), so thanks, y’all!
Honestly, I’ve been really happy with my boxes so far, and I’m also really happy with the customer service. I’ve reached out several times to their team with questions, and they’ve been super helpful, plus they even read my initial blog post so that was nice of them.
Which cheese looks the best to you? Did you also receive one of these boxes? What were your thoughts on it? Let me know in the comments and have a great day!
-AMS
https://whatever.scalzi.com/2025/05/07/an-appyhour-double-feature/
https://whatever.scalzi.com/?p=55545